The 2027 Borough Budget Has a Problem, and 5 Options to Solve It

The Problem Facing Chester Heights
Every household in Chester Heights knows what it means to spend more than it brings in. The Borough is in that position now, and not by accident.
The bare-bones 2027 budget presented to Council shows a gap of $299,943. That budget has no community events, no library support and no maintenance for the parks the Borough already owns. Put those things back, along with the zoning ordinance rewrite and routine costs, and the gap grows to $504,291.
This isn't a one-year problem. It's a structural deficit, meaning expenses that outrun recurring revenue every year until something changes.
How Did We Get Here?
For years the Borough balanced its budget on development: transfer taxes, building permits and one-time windfalls. That money was never reliable, and now it's gone.
There is no more development. The community has shown neither the appetite nor the room for it. The Borough bought 40 acres for a park instead of developing it. That was a choice many residents supported, and it left a hole in the budget.
Tax appeals are draining the budget. The Wawa appeal requires $69,000 in back-tax repayments, and the Madison appeal is estimated at another $50,000. Together that's $119,000, more than the roughly $112,000 the Borough collects in general operating property taxes. One year of appeals can erase an entire year of property tax revenue.
The easy fixes are used up. The Borough has already drawn down its savings to cover the gap.
The Options Before Council
Borough Council has five paths.
Option A: Wait. Do nothing this year, spend down reserves and plug the hole once more. The problem returns in 2028, with a smaller cushion and the same hole.
Option B: Raise property taxes. Property taxes bring in about $112,000 a year. Funding the bare-bones budget alone would take nearly four (4x) times today's level. Funding the real budget, the one with events, the library, park maintenance and the zoning rewrite, would take more than five (5x) times today's level. The entire burden would fall on homeowners, including seniors on fixed incomes.
Option C: Add an earned income tax and change nothing else. This is the ordinance on the November 16th agenda. As drafted, it imposes a 1% EIT and nothing more. It doesn't repeal the property tax. It doesn't repeal the fire tax. It doesn't set anything aside for the Fire Company. Passed as written, it asks residents to pay both taxes, roughly $340,000 a year more than the Borough needs.
Option D: One package. Pass a 1% earned income tax, eliminate the Borough's property taxes, including the fire tax, and dedicate 25% of EIT revenue to the Fire Company.
It closes the deficit, and keeps it closed.
It relieves residents living on Social Security alone.
It funds community events, the library and the parks.
Its effect on most households is small. About 55% of residents already pay earned income tax where they work, and that tax would now come to the Borough instead.
Option E: A smaller EIT, keep the fire tax. This sounds like a compromise, but the surplus runs out in about 15 years, and it leaves nothing for capital improvements or opening the 40-acre park to the public. It puts off the problem without solving it.
Why It Has to Be One Package?
Council doesn't need three separate ordinances to do this right. It can act on one coordinated package: the EIT ordinance, a 2027 budget that eliminates the Borough's property taxes, and a dedicated 25% share for the Fire Company. The simplest route is not the best one.
Think of the package as a three-legged stool.
An EIT without the property tax repeal means residents pay twice.
A repeal without the EIT means the Borough runs out of money.
Either one without the Fire Company share means asking the Fire Company to give up the dedicated funding it has relied on, and hoping.
Take away any leg, and the stool falls.
I am not speaking on behalf of the Fire Company. But the Fire Company has capital needs ahead, including a replacement fire truck expected to cost $1.4 million in about two years. A dedicated share of the EIT, written into the ordinance, lets it pay for operations and set money aside for equipment like this, instead of scrambling when the bill arrives. That protects every resident's safety. It also protects the Borough from an emergency bailout later.
But Isn't It Simpler to Keep the Fire Tax?
It is simpler. It's also the more expensive choice for residents. Keep the fire tax, and residents pay for fire protection through two taxes. Choose a dedicated share of the EIT, and the Fire Company gets the same stability, written into the ordinance and not reopened in every budget, with one fewer tax bill.
Simple isn't the same as right. The question to ask is: who pays, for how long, and what do we get?
What Council Should Do?
My recommendation is Option D.
I have more than 24 years in accounting and finance, a bachelor's degree in accounting and a Master of Public Administration. I spent ten years analyzing and reviewing the Borough budget and three years leading Council's finance committee. During that time I knew about the structural deficit. There was little appetite for raising taxes or restructuring, so we made modest changes and an earned income tax was never on the table.
The numbers have not changed since then. What has changed is that the options are running out.
Option D should be enacted as one coordinated package, so every piece depends on the others and none can be dropped later.
Disclosure: I am a Chester Heights resident and a volunteer member of the Chester Heights Fire Company. I am not paid by the Borough or the Fire Company and do not speak for them.
Have Questions or Concerns? Come to the Budget Meeting on November 16th
Council will hear from residents, so make sure it hears from you. If you want community services, lower taxes, and a Borough that can plan for the future, ask Council to vote for Option D, as one coordinated package.
ONE PAGE



Comments